I loved it. I was reading the ending during social studies,and my social studies teacher came up to me and ask if I was ok, since my fave character was killed, and I was "yeah, My heart will never heal though", which kinda freaked her out.

OMG OMG OMG!!!!!


I loved the book!!!!!!!!

I hated the ending. I knew it was coming when he was left in the Cave, but come on kill her mother at least we could almost cheer for that.

I just fininshed this a few minutes ago and now i want to go back and reread the books just to see them happy..... lol

I'm a sap and think they should have a some how happy ever after..... lol